Mr. Peter Lifland brought in a bountiful supply of bagels on Thursday at 7:20 a.m. He had made a point to get the bagels from Einstein’s extra early that day to get limited-edition extra cheesy bagels fresh out of the oven. Unfortunately, for him, four maybe-miscreants were also at Poly early. Before his students could arrive for morning help time to partake in the bagels and learn from his comp-sci/math wisdom, the entire box was stolen!
Now the bagels are gone, and the students are ravenous.
The bagels were last seen at 7:21 a.m. on the Math Office table. By 7:40 a.m., they were gone.
You’re the detective, and you need to discover who the bagel thief is. You have four suspects. Everyone claims to have an airtight alibi, but one of them is lying.
THE SUSPECTS:
- Mr. Vargo
- I was riding my bike to school when the chain suddenly snapped on Del Mar Blvd. I was on the street trying to get it fixed the entire time. Believe me, I wasn’t going anywhere.
- Mr. Prater
- I was in the gym trying to fix one of the volleyball nets. We can’t have our equipment broken before the season even starts!
- Ms. Bocquin
- I spent most of the morning in my classroom preparing for my students’ first period quiz. I passed by the math offices, but I never went inside.
- Mr. Taylor
- I had gone down to Boswell to see if they had any supplies to fix my skis. This weekend I accidentally cracked my left one when I landed on a rock!
CLUE: After exploring the crime scene, a distraught Mr. Peter Lifland noted that the Math Office printer had sustained recent water damage and was not working that morning. He discovered a soaking wet coat on the floor next to it.
CLUE: Mr. Vargo, an experienced cyclist, attributed his fall to an unexpected downpour of rain around 7:20. “It soaked me until I was shivering, and then it made the street so slick my bike was wobbling all over the place. It would have thrown off anyone!”
CLUE: A roadside assistance record confirms that Mr. Vargo called for help at 7:22 a.m on Lake. The mechanic’s service record confirms he did not leave until 7:38 a.m.
CLUE: A member of the Art Department provided Mr. Taylor with adequate glue to repair his skis, but required Mr. Taylor to work on the skis outside because there were renovations being done on the inside for a new gallery design.
CLUE: Ms. Stebbins remembered someone came in to print at Haaga House at 7:30 a.m, but as she was busy working, the only part of the person she noticed was their bright red umbrella. The umbrella was notable because no other teacher had brought one that day. The printer record shows that 20 quizzes were printed.
CLUE: An eyewitness saw Mr. Prater in the gym the entire morning working on the net, taking a brief break at 7:30 but returning at 7:33.



















