Upper School History Teacher Rick Caragher, a beloved educator, coach, colleague and friend, passed away on Tuesday, Oct. 27, 2026, after suffering from a stroke during a run the previous Sunday. His memorial will be held on Sunday, Dec. 13, at 1 pm in the Poly boys gym. Shae Caragher, his daughter, noted, “We don’t want anyone to wear black (wear orange or any colors or things that make you think of my dad).”
Throughout nearly four decades at Poly, Rick Caragher worked to build relationships that extended beyond the classroom and team practices, dedicating his life to the community and helping to shape the lives of generations of families. From greeting students at the front gate every morning to cheering them on at sports events and performances, Caragher’s irreplaceable presence on campus was defined by his reliability, passion and thoughtfulness.
Caragher was especially known for his friendly greetings every morning at the Upper School gate, asking about students’ plans for the day, their upcoming exams or their competitions over the weekend. Although his presence was nearly routine, his greetings were never impersonal.
“No matter what he was doing or where he had to be, he always stopped to say hi to you. Every day, he was at the front gate. Rain or shine,” reflected sophomore Allison Kennedy.
For Kennedy, interactions like this reflected a relationship that extended to her family. Before Kennedy came to Poly’s Upper School, Caragher already knew her mother and her older brother, senior Caiden Kennedy, whom he coached in cross country. After years of cheering on her older brother alongside Caragher at cross country meets, Allison Kennedy became a runner herself; soon Caragher was cheering her on, too.
Caragher’s presence at the gate remained reliable even during periods of immense difficulty. During the Eaton Fires in January of 2025, numerous Poly families suffered devastating losses. Despite losing his own home, Caragher returned to the front gate the day school resumed and asked other Upper School faculty to join him so that students would be warmly welcomed back to school with encouragement and consolation.
Caragher’s involvement across the Poly community makes it difficult to describe him with any single position or title. Since he began working at Poly in 1987, he has served as a history teacher, a cross country coach, a track and field coach, an assistant basketball coach and the director of PolyGlobal, formerly known as the Global Initiatives Program. He was also a warm and spirited colleague whose genuine interest and encouragement extended far beyond his own endeavors.
When asked how she would describe Caragher, Upper School World Languages Teacher Patricia Levin replied, “Extremely personable, caring and enthusiastic about pretty much everything. Witty, with a great, great, great sense of humor. A person that cared about everything, beyond what happened in his [own] environment.”
“It was visible and obvious to everybody in the room that he cared about both what he was teaching and each individual he used to teach,” shared Upper School History Teacher Lawrence Zellner.
“I feel like he was always such a big part of our community. He was also always at different sports events, and every single school event, like dance shows, performances, the performing arts, sports and spirit days. He was at everything and always showed the most enthusiasm,” junior Caroline Perez-Fraga said. “He had a really big interest in a lot of my activities and internships and just wanted to know more.”
His colleagues similarly experienced this thoughtfulness. Levin worked with Caragher for ten years, and her office neighbored Caragher’s for the last two.
She recalled their regular early-morning conversations and jokes: “Both of us, being early birds, were pretty much the only ones at school in the Fullerton building in the morning. He became my next door neighbor, every day for two years. We had at least a 10 minute conversation every morning.”
During a leave of absence last year, Levin recalls receiving consistent messages from Caragher, checking in every once in a while. She also playfully described some of his morning greetings: “There were a couple of phrases in Spanish that were not always in proper Spanish, but that I learned to appreciate.”
Throughout his time at Poly, Caragher taught both Middle and Upper School history classes, including tenth grade Perspectives on Modern World History, the former Western Civilizations course and eighth grade United States History.
“He had high expectations for people academically, and at the same time, [served] as a vehicle to help students understand the actual lived experience of people from the past,” shared Zellner. “Simulations were very important to him as a teacher, and I think a crucial part of how he thought about empathy, in regards to historical figures.”
“Mr. Caragher’s dedication to experiential learning played a dramatic role in my education and development. From ‘The Communist Manifesto’ to ‘Candide,’ Mr. Caragher blended the humanities with remarkable tact. It’s almost impossible to separate his teaching from his flair for the theatrical,” said alumnus Finnegan Keller ‘21, one of Caragher’s many students.

In addition to teaching history, Caragher served as Co-Director and then the sole Director of PolyGlobal for 17 of the program’s 20 years. Throughout his time leading the initiative, Caragher developed ideas for travel programs and led many of them with other faculty members. He also oversaw the Global Scholars Program, including teaching the Facing Global Challenges course for seniors. He also hosted numerous guest speakers to speak about a range of current global issues.
“For me, probably my favorite interactions were when he and I scouted Kazakhstan [for the PolyGlobal trip]. Just having him meet all the people I care about there was really special, so that means a lot to me,” shared Upper School Mathematics Teacher Amber Bocquin.
Caragher most recently chaperoned the Japan PolyGlobal trip this June, and he was especially passionate about the spring break trip to Cape Town, South Africa, where he led three student groups to connect with elementary school students through the tutoring program iThuba and study the legacy of apartheid and reconciliation.
“We are developing empathy, hearing perspective and getting comfortable with being uncomfortable around people that have different practices, different views and look differently,” reflected Caragher in the “South Africa trip sparks cross-cultural connection” article for the April 2026 issue of The Paw Print written by sophomore Angie Holleman. “But we can still fundamentally respect their humanity and their dignity.”

“Mr. Caragher was truly the kindest person, with the most caring and genuine soul. On my trip to South Africa, he encouraged us to try new things, fully immerse ourselves in the culture and connect deeply with the people around us,” shared junior Simone Jospe. “He both taught and showed us what it means to care for others and leave a positive mark everywhere you go. Going on that trip was honestly one of the best experiences of my life, and I will never forget how it changed the way I see the world. I will always carry his lessons and his kindness with me.”
Additionally, Caragher’s long athletic career displayed his commitment to the Poly community. He began his coaching career in 1988 as head coach of cross country. He spent a decade as head coach of track and field, as well as 16 years as assistant varsity coach for boys basketball.
As a cross country coach for 37 years, Caragher encouraged student athletes to step out of their comfort zones. He emphasized personal bests and strong efforts instead of solely focusing on race times or awards, and he was known for the individual attention that he paid to each athlete.
The list of Caragher’s achievements as a coach is extensive. In 1994, he brought an unranked girls cross country team all the way to CIF Finals, taking home the state championship against all odds. A few years later, in 1997, the girls cross country team came back to reclaim their second-ever CIF championship. In 2009, he coached runner Wesley Devoll ’10 to Poly’s only individual state championship. In the same year, the boys cross country team won second in the state overall. Caragher also helped runner Xian Shively ’18 break the Prep League cross country championship record with a three mile time of 14:54. In the spring of 2025, Caragher stepped down from his coaching position, leaving behind a legacy of dedication, hard work and genuine love of the sport.

Even after his coaching retirement, Caragher stayed active, frequently running and remaining informed on the team. Junior Kylie Cameron, who joined cross country the year after Caragher’s retirement, shared, “Even though I wasn’t under his direct coaching, he was always so nice, and he’d always come up to me and say, ‘oh, are you still injured? Are you healthy? How much are you running per week?’”
Caragher’s commitment to his students was matched only by his intense school spirit. Zellner recalled, “I remember him running around campus or around cross-country courses wearing… I think I counted at least 7 different shades of orange.” His famous orange outfits made him something of an icon at Poly’s games, where his enthusiasm was as recognizable as his bright-colored clothes.
That Poly spirit, along with his friendly rivalries with nearby schools, went hand-in-hand with meaningful friendships across the coaching community. His long tenure and dedication to cross country earned him the respect of competing coaches. On Saturday, Oct. 31, at the Prep League Finals cross country meet, the Flintridge Prep coach gave a tribute to Caragher’s devotion to the sport and kindness, even to rival coaches.
Caragher’s commitment left a lasting impression on his runners. On Sunday, Nov. 1, former Poly cross country runner Janna Wennberg ’14 hosted a Zoom meeting for his athletes to share memories of him, bringing together current students and alumni dating back to the class of 2006. Throughout the two hour meeting, current and former runners shared anecdotes like training with the Navy SEALs, seeing Caragher cheer runners on from the roof of the Poly van and discovering his creative team t-shirt designs. Above all, runners recalled the lessons he taught, of perseverance, grit and integrity, embodied in his slogans like “Be a Panther, not a Parasite!” or “Iron sharpens iron.”
Caragher also shared his devout Christian faith with the community, serving as the founding faculty advisor for the student-led affinity group Poly Christian Fellowship. He created early morning faculty prayer spaces as well, where teachers would meet to share scripture and prayer before starting their school days.
Caragher also served as a student advisor, mentoring advisees and supporting them through their academic and social pursuits.
“Mr. Caragher was my advisor of two years, sophomore year history teacher, senior year PolyGlobal teacher, United Nations Association advisor, Outdoor Education chaperone, and one of the most impactful mentors I have ever had. He exemplified what he preached and stood for integrity with the most admirable dedication, earnestly advocating for every student from the arts to athletics,” shared Maddie Delbridge ’26. “His care even extended beyond Poly, exchanging the most supportive emails up until less than a week before his passing. I will miss his supportive presence deeply but am so grateful to have experienced his wisdom and teaching.”

As Poly began mourning the loss of Caragher, students and colleagues looked for ways to express their gratitude and love for him, even after his passing. Perez-Fraga worked with Upper School World Languages Teacher and 11th Grade Coordinator Cynthia Garcia-Macedonio and Dean of Student Activities Laurianne Williams to create an ofrenda outside his office in the Fullerton building, honoring his life.
“By the end of the day, it was filled with photos, flowers, [and] notes,” Perez-Fraga said. “I felt really happy and touched by how much this ofrenda touched the entire community, and how they responded so quickly.”
The ofrenda even featured a bucket of Nature Valley granola bars, Caragher’s favorite snack that he’d often give out as a cross country treat.
The display brought together a wide array of experiences that occurred separately but all shared one common thread: a consistent purpose that Caragher strived to achieve across teaching, coaching and global education.
“He always wanted people to be the best versions of themselves, but he never wanted that to happen solely for their own self-interest. He always wanted that to happen so that they’d be giving to the community. They could be a part of something greater than themselves. And for him that had often been a team, or a class or whatever group it was, but it was always in the service of a larger goal,” Zellner said.
Caragher wanted students to improve, but to him, improvement was less about standing out individually and more about becoming someone who could contribute. A strong runner could help a team, and a thoughtful student could add to class discussion. A world traveler could develop their understanding of other peoples and cultures in order to build empathy and deeper connections across countries. A person willing to learn, grow, listen and participate could strengthen the relationships and community surrounding them, just as Caragher did every day.
At Poly, Caragher met his wife, Lisa, who founded and served as the head coach of the badminton program, until retiring after 32 years of working at the school. They had two daughters, Shae ‘17 and Keara ‘20, who are both Poly “lifers.” The Caraghers’ wedding took place at Founder’s Hall on April 1, 1995.
“Rick asked me to play violin at his and Lisa’s wedding. Whenever I hear the song he asked me to play, ‘As the Deer (Psalm 42),’ I think of their beautiful wedding and I think of Rick,” shared Iwasaki. “I’m so very grateful for Rick’s role and impact in my life and in the lives of so many.”
The Caragher family has been a cornerstone for the Poly community, leaving a lasting impact through their unwavering support of students and faculty both inside and beyond the classroom.
“Mr. Caragher was the first person to welcome me to California. I’m not from here, and he and his wife emailed me when I got the job, and they both continued, but he was the main one writing the emails to reach out and support me and just make me feel very welcomed, not just in Poly but in California in general. I actually stayed with them the first few days I moved here before I got settled, and I know from other teachers he did the same; he was the first person to welcome them,” reflected Bocquin.
Throughout his time at Poly, Caragher’s care usually took the form of everyday gestures: remembered conversations, birthday emails, follow-up questions or a familiar voice cheering from the sidelines. Over time, his gestures forged meaningful relationships, built off reliability and genuine interest. Caragher’s influence spanned across the world, and he was friends with people from many different schools, families, jobs, and walks of life. He left big shoes to fill.
But Caragher’s impact on the community persists. Although he will no longer greet us in the morning or be there to watch our games, he’s left behind something valuable for us to carry forward.
Poly’s community has already begun to grow in accordance with Caragher’s philosophy of giving to the community. Kennedy noted, “Doctora Bernath [Upper School World Languages Teacher Maite Bernath] is at the front gate now, saying ‘Hi’ to everyone each morning, which I think is good, so there’s not an empty space there.”
Kennedy also encourages students and teachers alike to check in with each other, and to take more of an interest in other people’s lives, carrying on Caragher’s legacy in small but meaningful ways. While his absence leaves a space no one person can fill, his example endures in the people he taught to look beyond themselves, show up for one another and bring their best for the benefit of their community.




















